Pit Boss Vs Traeger Pellet Grills: The Ultimate Brand comparison in 2022

BBQ is booming, and people are warming to pellet grills, a great new way to enjoy a barbecue. One question they may have: What are the best brands in BBQ? Look no further than Traeger and Pit Boss, who offer the most comprehensive pellet grill options. If you have done any digging into pellet grills, you might find that the names Pit Boss and Traeger are prominent. Both brands are well-known within this niche and are worth considering.

People always defend the grill they bought and slam the competition, so it’s hard to get an objective opinion. It makes sense that people new to both brands may want to compare the two. This will, of course, have a significant impact on their final buying decision. We will now discuss some best pellet grills from the pit boss and Traeger pellet to provide ease in selecting your desired one.

Pit Boss Brand Overview:

Pit Boss was one of Traeger’s earliest competitors. It all started in 1999 when Dan Thiessen, the CEO of Danson’s Inc., created a subsidiary for his company. At that point, he named it Pit Boss Grills after his surname. This new branch of Danson’s would focus on creating smoker grills that were less expensive than Traegers to deliver competitively priced pellet smokers out into the market.

Thiessen contracted with Joe Hruska and Jack Wakin to develop this line. They became widely known as the Black Label Series. The popularity of these manufacturing products rose immensely among consumers resulting in many restaurants participating in catering using Pit Boss Grills and Pellet Smokers.

Traeger Pellet Brand Overview:

Traeger is now the only real heavyweight in the pellet grill market. However, Traeger wasn’t a business until around 1985, when Joe Traeger began experimenting with wood-burning stoves and developed his first pellet grill after filing for a patent in 1986. They sold the Traeger for the next twenty years to consumers with the help of smaller dealerships that supplied BBQ parts and accessories till the rejected patent expired in 2006. After that, brothers Tom and Vance Cook purchased the company.

Shortly after taking control, the Cooks relocated production to Utah to establish themselves as a leading manufacturer of grills for friends and family while providing a wide selection of alternatives to local purchasers looking to save money.

Pit Boss Vs Traeger Pellet Grills comparison

Let see the comprehensive comparison between the both brands in order to give you a clear idea that what to go for.

Temperature Control:

If we look to Traeger based on the heat retention feature, it plays a vital role. The cooking chamber of Traeger is composed of two stainless steel to perform better for heat-storing. Thus, there is no chance of escaping heat from Traeger chambers during the coldest days. Its temperature increments can be regulated at 15°F, but some can be set at 5°F. On the counter side, the pit boss also plays a vital role in retaining the heat. Still, the temperature dial can be adjusted or set at increments of 25°F, which is a somehow high range.

Hopper Capacity:

No matter their size, Traeger pellet grills have hoppers that will hold 20 pounds of pellets which is enough cooking space to prepare BBQ for multiple people. Pit Boss grills generally have anywhere from 5–27-pound hopper capacities, with the largest available for newer models. However, most Pit Boss’s grills can hold at least 20 pounds of pellets.

Designed-Material Quality:

The Traeger Pellet grill is the best high-end pellet grill because it has stainless-steel material-based construction that lasts for a long time. On the other hand, the Pit Boss is also made of stainless steel, running for a long time. As a result, both brands provide the best quality products.

Price:

Pit Boss is a brand known for making charcoal grills and smokers that cost a fraction of Traeger grills. However, when it comes time to compare the two brands, you must consider more than just the money you spend. The Pit Boss is cheaper than the Traeger, but it still does quality work, which means that you’re still getting lots of value for your dollar.

Cooking area:

If you’re buying a pellet grill for a family and everyone wants to have the same tests in every food, go with the larger model from Traeger or pit boss. Both are good enough to provide ample cooking space to feed a large group of people or families at once. You go with any one of these two because both provide ample cooking space where you will need to cook again.

Warranty:

Pit Boss offers a 5-Year Protection Plan on their pellet grills, which means that if you have any mechanical issues, you can send the grill back and get it repaired. Traegers only have warranty Protection of 3 years which is not better than the pit boss warranty.

Comprehensive Comparison Chart of top three Pit Boss Vs Traeger Pellet Grills

Full Detailed Review of Top three Traeger Pellet Grills

Traeger Pellet Grills TFB57PZBO

Are you looking for a pellet cooker with a bronze finish and a barrel-style design? At the same time, there are several excellent choices on the market. Still, the TFB57PZBO Traeger grill offers 572 sq. inches of cooking space and porcelain-coated steel construction. So, when you want to purchase an attractive and durable grill, always keep in mind that quality is more important than quantity.

Moreover, it comes with multiple features which are very user-friendly. It features an electronic automatic ignition – you don’t need to worry about using a fire starter. You can easily set the Temperature of this smoker by simply turning a dial and checking the Temperature using a digital display, something that’s also easy to do. The convenient settings enable you to cook low and slow, ideal for smoking meat and fish of different kinds. Additionally, it includes two probes that monitor your smoking temperature while giving you more control over how your food turns out. 

Pros
  • Stainless steel parts
  • 572 Sq. In cooking capacity
  • Automatic adjustable Temperature
  • Super easy to clean and use
Cons
  • Limited accessories available

Traeger Grills Tailgater 20 Portable Wood Pellet Grill

It is a 300 Square feet versatile pellet grill for a large family to cook twelve burgers or two whole chickens. The Tailgater 20 grill has an adjustable thermostat with a temperature range of 180 to 450 degrees Fahrenheit, so you will not have any trouble keeping the desired temperature you want when cooking. In addition to its versatility, you can use this pellet grill for grilling or smoking, depending on what type of food you plan to cook on it.

However, the hopper can be easily isolated, which provides easiness in adding wood without disturbing the energetic flame of fire. If you want to have cooked in the mountains or hell or any outing place, this is also the best choice because it is lightweight and easily carried. One of the great things about this grill is its folding legs which means that you can store it in small spaces.

Pros
  • Multiple temperature settings
  • Digital controller
  • Portable and traditional barrel shape
  • Lightweight and compact
Cons
  • Small hopper can run out of fire if you don’t monitor closely

Traeger Grills Ranger Portable Wood Pellet Grill 

If you’re looking to purchase a wood grill that you can take along with you on your travels, keep little space, but have built-in high quality, then step right to the Traeger Grills Ranger mini, which is a great choice. If you have picnics or pool parties, you won’t endure any hassles while taking it. This electrically powered drill feeds tiny worm-shaped hardwood pellets into a firebox. They are burned, and smoke is produced by the heat released.

However, being small and compact tough, it provides 184 sq. in along with an 8-pound sizeable hopper capable of cooking meals for up to 4 people. You can adjust the temperature using an arched controller, which displays the temperature settings in large numerals to avoid confusing anyone when you’re cooking a meal. Moreover, the grates are made of porcelain which can resist rusting and provides easiness in cleaning. For safe, secure transportation, it is designed with two lid latches.  

Pros
  • Portable and durable
  • Dual-hinged lids
  • Porcelain-coated grates
  • Digital Arc Controller
  • Easy to use
Cons
  • No wi-fi connectivity

Full Detailed Review of Top three Pit Boss Pellet Grills

PIT BOSS 71700FB 700FB Pellet Grill, 700 Series

This grill is incredibly versatile. It can reach up to 600 degrees Fahrenheit, and it comes with a flame broiler system. The Pit Boss digital temperature control makes sure that your cooking experience remains constant and that it’s as easy as can be to set the temperature. There’s the convenience of a digital controller, so you won’t have to stand by and monitor the heat levels or worry about the food getting cold. At the same time, you wait for the correct cooking temperature. The hopper offers 20 pounds of pellets, ensuring that your grill will always have plenty of fuel.

The Pit Boss Elite 700 has a total cooking area of 700 square inches. Now that is big, and one of the large pellet grills on the market today is plenty enough for most purposes. Furthermore, it is safe to say that this pit would be ideal for tailgating or large gatherings at home with your family or friends. This model comes with wheels that help you lug it everywhere easily. So, you can wheel it up and down stairs without any inconvenience whatsoever.

Pros
  • Variable temperature
  • 700 sq. in. of cooking capacity
  • Digital controller
  • Bottom storage shelf
Cons
  • Uneven temperature control

PIT BOSS 10537 PB0820SP Wood Pellet Grill

If you are looking for a smoker who allows you to do different things, check out the Pit Boss 10537 Wood Pellet Grill. It will enable you to smoke and grill at temperatures up to 500 degrees but also, but it’s suitable for use as a roaster and a baking oven. The Pit Boss offers a total cooking area of 849 square inches, enough to make a meal in batches for a large family gathering or prepare food for yourself. This great smoker was made of 16-gauge steel to be formidable while not too heavy when transported. It has sturdy wheels, so there is no trouble making the journey from your patio into storage which will also help keep it clean.

It is possible to monitor the temperatures using either one of two methods which are dial-in touch controls or an LED display. The pellet grill comes with meat probes for basting, perfectly browning, roasting, and warming purposes that are five times stronger than your average thermometer. S all these features, this is one of the best pellet barbecue thermometers you can find, so you won’t have to go hunting for another.

Pros
  • Eight cooking function
  • Meat probs and Internal wood pellet storage
  • 21 lbs. hopper capacity
  • LED display
Cons
  • The heating area is small as compared to others

Pit Boss Grills 75275 Stainless Steel Two-Burner Portable Grill

Are you searching for a portable Pit Boss grill but don’t want to spend too much? The two-burner Pit Boss 200P is one of the best choices for you as it comes with a full-body construction, 304 stainless steel grates, and a heavy-duty design. It is propane-fueled and equipped with a push-and-turn ignition switch and a built-in lid thermometer. The best part about this low-priced grill is that a five-year warranty backs it for burners and other components for only one year, but you rarely use them. It’s built like a tank and ready for some serious tailgating.

The Pit Boss’s 275 square inches of cooking surface provides enough area to feed a large crowd of people and can accommodate your largest gatherings because of high-quality materials. The design allows the grill to let you carry with ease, and its folding legs will enable you to stand it up quickly. Two 10,000 BTUs come with this model, making it an excellent choice for barbecuing meat or slow-cooking plates to get the most exceptional flavor from your food.

Pros
  • Push and Turn Ignition System
  • Lightweight and smaller in size
  • Two burners
  • Temperature control
Cons
  • Small as compared to others

Final Thoughts:

Hopefully, the above in-depth comparison of the Traeger Grills and Pit Boss Grills will help you make your mind up. Although all grills perform well for grilling, additional factors such as size, weight, convenience, and cleaning techniques tailored to your specific needs decide which grill is ideal for you. The Traeger and Pit Boss outdoor grills have durable construction and provide ample capacity. In short, you will find out that both brands design products with thought, and they deliver outstanding performance in different cooking workloads.

However, both Pit Boss and Traeger have a lot of aspects that make their products unique. Purchasing either one could be a great decision, which may work out best for you depending on your personal preferences. However, consider getting a Pit Boss unit instead if you cannot justify the higher cost and want to see some savings when purchasing your desired model.

FAQs:

Are stainless steel grill grates better than cast iron?

Stainless steel grates are a more durable alternative to cast iron grates. They are easy to clean and maintain but susceptible to premature wear, and food can stick to them more often. High-end stainless-steel grates will be more expensive than cast iron grates.

Can you sear on a Traeger?

Yes, you can sear food items on Traeger. The Traeger has a grilling chamber, which gives a nice smoky flavor with flame marks. You will love using Traeger’s grill for the crust, seafood, wings, and sometimes ribs.